“The Murders in the Rue Morgue“
starts out with a proposition: there are two modes of untangling a problem. The first is that of the chess player, who looks at all the pieces on a board and decides, from the way everything is laid out, what to do next. The second is that of the whist player (whist, by the way, is like bridge, a game with four players that depends on working out what cards your opponents are holding).The whist player not only has to memorize the rules and moves of the game (like the chess player) but she also has to figure out, or deduce, from watching her fellow players, what cards they have. This kind of analysis takes both imagination and reason – and it’s this kind of intelligence that we’re supposed to see in this story. (Check out our “In a Nutshell” for more on Poe and “tales of ratiocination” to see why this argument is important.)
If you’re looking for someone who has this whist-player-style analytical intelligence, look no further than our young, sarcastic protagonist, Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin, a Parisian gentleman fallen on hard times. Dupin’s love of detecting leads him to a case that both the newspapers and the police themselves have declared unsolvable: the murders in the Rue Morgue (a.k.a. Morgue Street).
The title of the story is straightforward — that is, the murders take place in the street (the Rue) of the Morgue. In the opening section of the story, Poe offers some of the views expressed above about the need of the detective to be observant (more than the ordinary person), and, furthermore, he must know what to observe. The most casual movement or expression can often reveal more than the magnifying glass which M. Dupin never uses, even though the police constantly rely on one to help them solve crimes. And also too, the superlative detective must be able to make the proper inferences from the things he observes. Here is where ingenuity becomes the most important aspect in solving a crime.
The narrator first met Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin when they were looking for a rare volume in a library; shortly, therefore, they became friends and shared an old house together. In later detective fiction, this convention is repeated; the brilliant detective and his sidekick will often share the same living abode. The narrator then gives us an example of M. Dupin’s brilliant analytical ability. Strolling along the street one night, the narrator is thinking about a certain actor, and suddenly M. Dupin answers without the narrator’s ever having asked anything. Then M. Dupin explains how through the logic of their previous conversation and by observing certain actions in his friend’s movements, he was able to deduce at what point his friend had come to a certain conclusion.
With “The Murders in the Rue Morgue,” Edgar Allan Poe introduces the prototype of the quintessential detective, in the form of Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin, whose theory and powers of analysis are displayed by his skill in solving a seemingly intractable case and explained by his friend’s opening monologue. Poe refers to Dupin’s method as ratiocination, in which Dupin uses not only logic but also creativity in solving his case. As with Sherlock Holmes and Hercules Poirot, two fictional detectives that later follow Dupin’s lead, Dupin allows the police to do most of the grunt work before stepping in for his own investigations and formulating his theories from his home rather than from a police station. He disparages the police for lacking creative insight because the key to Dupin’s analytical aptitude lies in his ability to imagine the mind of his opponents and to use his understanding of how others think to reconstruct their thoughts – and therefore their actions – in his mind.
Related articles
- Dark Tales: Edgar Allan Poe’s The Gold Bug: Dupin needs your help! (rvd2.typepad.com)
- Books to read when you are in a funk (kirstenhwhyte.wordpress.com)
- The Poe Shadow by Matthew Pearl (readingtothemax.wordpress.com)
- Edgar Allan Poe – The Master of Macabre (meetmeatthebookparade.wordpress.com)
- Mathematical Reason, Poets and the Purloined Letter (echovar.com)
- Lessons from Poe: Detecting the Inner Mediator – Join us this May in Baltimore (westallen.typepad.com)
- A Short History of Detective Fiction (interestingliterature.wordpress.com)
- Barry’s mailbox (gnostalgia.wordpress.com)
- The Crime Fiction Handbook by Peter Messent – review (guardian.co.uk)
- Chess and 18th Century artificial intelligence (bbc.co.uk)
Related articles
- The Poe Shadow by Matthew Pearl (readingtothemax.wordpress.com)
- Lessons from Poe: Detecting the Inner Mediator – Join us this May in Baltimore (westallen.typepad.com)
- Mathematical Reason, Poets and the Purloined Letter (echovar.com)
- Review: Nevermore (gnostalgia.wordpress.com)
- Edgar Allan Poe and how his Works & Poems Influenced my writing and My Life (shanesbookblog.com)